# Slow Bloom — structural check brief

**This document is an input package, not an analysis.** It contains no structural design, no
allowable stresses, no code load combinations and no conclusion about adequacy. Producing any of
those is the work of a **licensed structural engineer**, and it has deliberately not been attempted
here: the project brief for Slow Bloom is form and concept, and structural engineering is out of
scope. What this document does is assemble, in one place and with the arithmetic shown, everything
an engineer needs to start — the geometry as drawn, what the piece weighs and where that weight
sits, how much area the wind hits and how far those areas are from the base, what the foundation
currently assumes, and the specific questions to put to him.

Mike's decision 5 (2026-11-01): **the check happens before any metal is cut.** Nothing is ordered,
cut or welded until it comes back.

Companion documents: `docs/slow-bloom.md` (the concept sheet this geometry comes from),
`docs/slow-bloom-bom.json` (the priced bill of materials), `docs/references.md` (where the wind
speed and frost depth come from), `output/slow-bloom-load-inputs.json` (the raw input data), and
`scripts/slow_bloom_loads.py` (the tool that computes every number in sections 3 and 4).

---

## 1. The piece, in one paragraph

A single 4 in steel pipe mast, 7 ft 6 in clear above grade, cast into a concrete pier. On top of the
mast, through one slewing ring bearing, sits a 12 ft horizontal boom pivoted 4 ft from its butt —
so 4 ft of counterweight arm and 8 ft of arm reaching out and over. Five vertical bloom stalks rise
off that arm, shorter toward the tip, each carrying a 13-1/4 in shallow stainless bowl cut in half
and re-set as a two-lobe drag rotor that spins in the wind. The arm yaws with the wind, leans 3–8°
against urethane pads and eases back. Overall height 11 ft 6 in; overall reach 12 ft 4 in from the
mast; moving parts about 156 lb.

The load path, top to bottom: bloom rotors → stalks → boom → nod yoke and pin → **the slewing ring**
(all the moving weight and all the wind on the moving parts passes through this one bearing) →
fixed head plate → mast → base plate and gussets → four screw anchors → concrete pier → soil.

---

## 2. Geometry as drawn

| Item | As drawn | Source |
|---|---|---|
| Mast | 4 in nominal Schedule 40 pipe, 4.50 in OD x 0.237 in wall, A500 ERW, 90 in long, 7 ft 6 in clear above grade | BOM A4 |
| Mast section properties | A = 3.17 in², I = 7.24 in⁴, S = 3.22 in³, 10.79 lb/ft, 81.1 lb | computed from the section |
| Base plate | A36, 12 x 12 x 3/4 in, welded to the foot of the mast, 30.7 lb | BOM A5 |
| Base gussets | four 2 x 2 x 1/4 in A36 angle, 8 in long, welded between plate and mast | BOM A6 |
| Anchors | four 3/4 in x 8-1/2 in Simpson Strong-Tie Titen HD screw anchors, post-installed into the cured pier | BOM A7 |
| Pier | 12 in diameter, **36 in below finished grade plus 2 in proud**, 38 in of form and pour | BOM A1, A2 |
| Pier reinforcement | 4 x #4 (1/2 in) A615 Grade 40 vertical bars, wired cage | BOM A3 |
| Boom | 2-1/2 in OD x 0.120 in wall A513 welded tube, 12 ft long, pivoted 4 ft from the butt, 36.7 lb | BOM D1 |
| Bloom stalks | 1-1/2 in OD x 0.120 in wall, five at 40 / 34 / 28 / 22 / 16 in, mass total 20.7 lb | BOM D2 |
| Blooms | five rotors, each 14.5 in wide over the lobes x 4 in tall, 13-1/4 in bowl diameter, 2.6 lb each | BOM E1-E5 |
| Bloom centres | 6 ft 0 in, 7 ft 5 in, 8 ft 10 in, 10 ft 2 in, 11 ft 7 in from the boom butt; 42, 36, 30, 24, 18 in above the boom | concept sheet §2.1 |
| Main ring | igus iglide PRT-01-100-DD, 185 mm (7.28 in) slewing ring, fully sealed, dry-running polymer sliding elements | BOM B1 |
| Head plates | two A36 7 x 7 x 1/2 in plates — one fixed to the mast top, one rotating on the ring | BOM B2 |
| Nod pivot | 1 in 1018 bar, 7 in, through two UCFL205-16 flange bearing units bolted to the yoke cheeks | BOM C1, C2 |
| Counterweight | two 25 lb cast iron plates on a 1 in stub welded coaxially into the boom butt, sliding over 5 in | BOM C4, D4 |
| Overall | 11 ft 6 in high, 12 ft 4 in reach | concept sheet §2.1 |

Coordinates used throughout: **x** is distance along the boom from the yaw (ring) axis, positive
outboard, negative at the counterweight; **z** is height above finished grade. The whole mechanism —
ring, yoke, boom centreline — sits at z = 7.5 ft.

---

## 3. Dead load, itemised

Computed from `output/slow-bloom-load-inputs.json` by `scripts/slow_bloom_loads.py`. Tube masses come
from the section formula `mass = 12 pi rho t (D - t)` per foot (which is where the 10.68 t (D - t)
rule of thumb for steel comes from), plate masses from A36 at 0.284 lb/in³ and 316 stainless at
0.290 lb/in³, and masses that are neither (bowls, cast iron plates, fasteners) are declared directly
on the line with their source.

### 3.1 Rotating assembly — everything carried through the main ring: **156.53 lb**

| Piece | Mass (lb) | x (ft) | Moment (ft·lb) |
|---|---|---|---|
| Boom tube, 12 ft | 36.69 | +2.00 | +73.4 |
| Counterweight, 2 x 25 lb plates | 50.00 | −4.25 | −212.5 |
| Five bloom rotors (bowl, hub, caps, axle, bearings) | 13.00 | +4.80 | +62.4 |
| Five bloom stalks | 20.68 | weighted +4.20 | +86.8 |
| Five stalk collars | 2.67 | +4.60 | +12.3 |
| Fulcrum cross-tubes, 4 x 6 in | 6.12 | 0.00 | 0.0 |
| Rotating head plate, 7 x 7 x 1/2 in | 6.96 | 0.00 | 0.0 |
| Nod yoke cheeks, 2 off 8 x 6 x 1/4 in | 6.82 | 0.00 | 0.0 |
| Bowl-to-hub clamps | 4.25 | +4.80 | +20.4 |
| Stainless fasteners in the rotating group | 4.00 | +4.00 | +16.0 |
| Five axle sleeves and spacers | 0.56 | +4.80 | +2.7 |
| Nod pivot pin, 7 in | 1.56 | 0.00 | 0.0 |
| Counterweight stub, 5 in | 1.12 | −4.20 | −4.7 |
| Yoke brackets and gussets | 1.60 | 0.00 | 0.0 |
| Boom end caps and weep fittings | 0.50 | +4.00 | +2.0 |
| **Total** | **156.53** | CG at **+0.38 ft** | **+58.9** |

**A correction the engineer should know about.** The concept sheet said "about 90 lb (arm 37 lb,
stalks and hubs 20 lb, blooms 12 lb, counterweight 50 lb, hardware)" — a parenthetical that summed
to 119 lb against a stated 90. Itemising it properly gives **156.5 lb**, of which 50 lb is the
counterweight. Use 156.5 lb, not 90. The figure that matters most for the ring is that **the ring
carries 156.5 lb of axial load as its normal condition.**

**Two derived quantities the engineer will want:**

- **Dead-load imbalance: +58.9 ft·lb, bloom-heavy**, i.e. the centre of gravity of the whole
  rotating assembly sits **0.38 ft (4.5 in) outboard of the pivot**. This is intentional — the
  design wants the arm resting lightly against the lean pads so they are always preloaded — but the
  pads, the yoke and the nod pin all see it as a static offset load, and the ring sees it as a
  permanent standing tilt moment.
- **Counterweight trim authority: only 20.8 ft·lb.** The two plates slide along a 5 in stub and
  nowhere else, so 50 lb x 0.417 ft is the entire adjustment range available to trim the arm at
  dry-fit. Against a 58.9 ft·lb imbalance that is a narrow window: if the built arm comes out
  further out of balance than the drawing implies, the fix is a heavier plate or a longer stub, not
  more slide. Worth knowing before the counterweight is welded in.

### 3.2 Fixed assembly — carried straight down the mast: **127.76 lb**

Mast pipe 81.13 lb · base plate 30.67 lb · four base gussets 8.50 lb · fixed head plate 6.96 lb ·
drip hat 0.50 lb.

**Total structure: 284.3 lb**, of which 156.5 lb is above the ring and 127.8 lb is mast and foot.

---

## 4. Wind

### 4.1 Design wind speed

**115 mph, 3-second gust, Exposure Category C** — Grand County's Design Criteria and adopted code,
with the county's own note that "special wind regions exist in Grand County". Source and the
discrepancy between the county's various published values: `docs/references.md` §2. The site is in
the Grand Lake / Kremmling area at roughly 7,300 ft.

The bare code velocity pressure at this height is **qz = 0.00256 V² Kz = 28.8 psf** (Kz = 0.85,
Exposure C, 0-15 ft band — the whole piece is inside it, topping out at 11.5 ft).

**That 28.8 psf is an input, not a design pressure.** ASCE 7's Kd, gust factor G, the shape factor
for a 12 ft round tube carrying five open drag rotors, and any county requirement for a
site-specific speed in a special wind region are all the engineer's to apply, and they will move
this number in both directions.

### 4.2 Wind-catch areas and their lever arms

| Surface | Projected area (sq ft) | x (ft) | z (ft) | Area·x | Area·z |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| Bloom 1 rotor | 0.263 | +2.00 | 11.00 | 0.53 | 2.89 |
| Bloom 2 rotor | 0.263 | +3.42 | 10.50 | 0.90 | 2.76 |
| Bloom 3 rotor | 0.263 | +4.83 | 10.00 | 1.27 | 2.63 |
| Bloom 4 rotor | 0.263 | +6.17 | 9.50 | 1.62 | 2.50 |
| Bloom 5 rotor | 0.263 | +7.58 | 9.00 | 1.99 | 2.37 |
| All five blooms | **1.315** | +4.80 | 10.00 | 6.31 | 13.15 |
| Bloom stalks (140 in of 1-1/2 in tube) | 1.458 | +4.65 | 8.60 | 6.78 | 12.54 |
| Boom tube (2-1/2 in x 12 ft) | 2.500 | +2.00 | 7.50 | 5.00 | 18.75 |
| End caps, collars, counterweight | 1.000 | −2.00 | 7.50 | −2.00 | 7.50 |
| Head plates and nod yoke | 1.000 | 0.00 | 7.40 | 0.00 | 7.40 |
| **Rotating total** | **7.273** | — | — | **16.09** | **59.34** |
| Mast itself (4.50 in x 7.5 ft, fixed, not through the ring) | 2.810 | 0.00 | 3.75 | 0.00 | 10.54 |
| **Total** | **10.083** | — | — | **16.09** | **69.88** |

Reading of that table: the effective horizontal lever arm of the whole wind-catch is **1.60 ft**
(ΣA·x / ΣA), and the effective height is **6.93 ft** above grade. The blooms are 1.3 sq ft of the
10.1 total — the boom and stalks are two-thirds of the area, which is worth knowing before anyone
tunes the design around the blooms alone.

**How the bloom area was arrived at, because it is the one number that needs an argument.** The bowl
is a spherical cap, 13.25 in chord and 4 in deep, which gives a sphere radius of
R = (r² + h²)/2h = 7.49 in and a circular-segment area of R²(θ − sinθ)/2 with θ = 2 asin(r/R) =
2.1726 rad → 37.9 sq in = **0.263 sq ft** per rotor, viewed from any direction: the two halves are
offset ±1.5 in and do not overlap in projection, so the two lobes together read the same as the
whole bowl. The *Savonius convention* is different — the rotor's performance is referenced to the
full 14.5 in x 4 in rectangle, 0.403 sq ft — but that is the area for computing the rotor's
efficiency, not the area the wind loads the structure with. Both are in the input file; if the
engineer wants the conservative one for load, it is the 0.403.

### 4.3 An order-of-magnitude indication — **not a design load**

qz (28.8 psf) x projected area, with a shape factor bracketed between 1.0 and 2.0, no Kd, no gust
factor, no load combination, no importance factor:

| Assumed shape factor | Total horizontal force | Resultant offset from the mast axis | Overturning moment at grade |
|---|---|---|---|
| 1.0 | 290 lb | 463 ft·lb | 2,011 ft·lb |
| 2.0 | 580 lb | 926 ft·lb | 4,022 ft·lb |

**This is the arithmetic that says the check is not optional.** It is not a design value, it is not
a code load, and it must not be used as one — the engineer's factors will move it. But a horizontal
force in the hundreds of pounds applied 7 to 11 ft above grade, on a 12 in diameter pier 36 in deep,
is the shape of problem this brief exists to hand over.

### 4.4 Load cases beyond the plain one

Called out because a piece like this invites them and the engineer should rule on each:

- **Ice on the blooms and stalks** in a winter gust — added area and added weight, on the parts
  most likely to be damaged by it.
- **Dynamic amplification.** The arm's lean is a spring-and-stop system with a 3–6 s period, and the
  blooms spin; at 115 mph the structure has to be checked as dynamic, not just static.
- **Maintenance and misuse load** — a person's weight on the tip of the arm or hanging from a
  bloom. Someone will do it.
- **Seismic.** Probably not governing for a 284 lb structure in this county, but it is a question
  for the engineer rather than an assumption.
- **Frost heave** on the pier, and the lateral soil pressure needed to resist a moment of this size
  in a 12 in shaft (L/D = 3). The pier is slender and relies on soil, not on its own weight: the
  concrete in a 12 in x 38 in pier weighs about 360 lb, which is a small fraction of the
  overturning moment above.
- **Altitude.** At 7,300 ft the air is thinner than the standard density behind the 0.00256
  coefficient — about a 17% lower pressure for the same speed. It cuts the other way for the drag
  rotors, which need the air to drive them, but the engineer should decide which density applies.

---

## 5. Foundation and anchorage as drawn — the assumptions being checked

These are assumptions, not decisions. They are what the concept sheet drew; the engineer is expected
to change them.

| Assumption | As drawn | Confidence |
|---|---|---|
| Pier diameter | 12 in | a design assumption, not a calculation |
| Pier embedment | 36 in below grade + 2 in proud (38 in total) | 36 in is the adopted frost depth, so this is a code-derived minimum, not a capacity check |
| Concrete | 5 x 80 lb bags of Quikrete 1101 bagged concrete mix | **no strength is cited anywhere in this bill.** Site-mixed bagged concrete is not a plant mix; whether the engineer will accept it for a structural pier, and at what strength, is his call |
| Reinforcement | 4 x #4 A615 Grade 40 verticals, "wired cage" | **no ties or spirals are specified.** A cage of four verticals with no ties is not a column cage; if the pier has to resist bending, he needs to say what ties he wants and at what spacing |
| Anchors | 4 x 3/4 in x 8-1/2 in Titen HD, post-installed into the cured pier, zinc plated | see 6.1 — the pattern does not currently fit the pier |
| Soil | unknown | **no geotechnical information exists for this site.** Nothing in this project has probed the ground |
| Water | pier struck 2 in proud, brushed finish, no cap or chamfer | ponding against the anchors and plate |
| Drip hat over the ring | the inverted 1 qt bowl (B3) sheds water off the ring gap, four 3/8 in drain holes in the fixed plate | already in the design |

---

## 6. Three things in the drawing the engineer should look at first

Not because they are wrong on purpose, but because they are the places where a form document drawn
around a *look* is most likely to have drawn a structural impossibility without noticing that is
what it was doing.

### 6.1 The anchor pattern does not fit inside the pier

The base plate is **12 in square**; the pier is **12 in diameter**. Only the inscribed 12 in circle
is concrete. Four anchors set on a plausible 8 in square pattern (1.5 in anchor centres inside the
plate edge) sit at (±4, ±4) in from the centre, i.e. 5.66 in from the centre of the pier — leaving
**0.34 in of concrete between the anchor and the face of the pier.** Pull the pattern in to a 6 in
square and the edge distance is 1.76 in on a 3/4 in anchor. There may be no pattern that works in a
12 in shaft at this load; the options are more pier diameter, a different anchor type, or a
different base connection. **The engineer should set the anchor pattern and the pier diameter
together, not inherit this one.**

### 6.2 The rebar cage has no ties

Four verticals with no ties is a sketch of a cage, not a cage. If the pier is being asked to resist
a bending moment — and section 4.3 suggests it is — the reinforcement detailing is his to specify.

### 6.3 The base plate overhangs the pier, and the pier is slender

A 12 in square plate on a 12 in round pier has corners 2.49 in proud of the concrete. That is
survivable — the plate spans the bearing circle and the anchors take the moment — but combined with
a 12 in shaft resisting a moment at the base it is the second thing to check.

---

## 7. The questions to put to the engineer

1. What code basis and which load combinations do you want to use here — which edition of the IBC
   and ASCE 7, and does Grand County's "special wind region" note require a site-specific wind speed
   above the 115 mph in the adopted criteria?
2. Given 10.1 sq ft of wind-catch area at an effective height of 6.9 ft and an effective horizontal
   offset of 1.6 ft from the mast axis — and given that the whole moving assembly yaws, so the
   exposed area can be at any bearing relative to the wind — what do you want as the governing wind
   case?
3. What shape factors will you apply to the five open drag rotors, the round boom and the round
   stalks? The rotor reference areas are in section 4.2 both ways; tell us which to use.
4. **Is the 12 in x 38 in pier adequate** — for overturning, for lateral soil bearing, and for
   deflection at the top of the mast under the design wind? If not, what diameter and depth do you
   want, and does the answer change if the ground turns out to be loose or frozen?
5. What soil parameters are you assuming, and do you need a geotechnical investigation before you
   can answer question 4? Nothing is currently known about the ground.
6. **What anchor pattern and what pier diameter do you want, given that the current 12 in square
   plate on a 12 in round pier leaves almost no edge distance** (section 6.1)?
7. Will you accept site-mixed bagged concrete for the pier, and at what compressive strength? If
   not, what mix do you require?
8. **What reinforcement do you want in the pier?** The current "four #4 verticals, wired cage" has no
   ties specified (section 6.2).
9. What do you require for the **mast-to-base-plate weld** — full penetration, fillet size, and is
   the 3/4 in plate thick enough without a stiffener? Section properties: the mast is 4.50 in OD x
   0.237 in wall, or I = 7.24 in⁴ / S = 3.22 in³.
10. **The main slewing ring is the single point everything passes through** — 156.5 lb of axial
    load permanently, plus all the wind on the moving parts as a tilt moment. We will obtain igus'
    load tables for the PRT-01-100 and their permissible tilt moment; will you confirm the moment
    from your wind case is inside them, or do you want a different ring?
11. What period and damping should we assume for the arm's lean motion, and do you want a dynamic
    check on the cantilever rather than a static one?
12. What maintenance, misuse or ice load do you want us to check against — and would you rule on
    whether the existing lean-stop arrangement (four urethane pads) is the right thing to be taking
    that load?
13. What tolerance do you want on the mast's plumb, and how much out-of-plumb can the pier tolerate
    before the lean mechanism has to be shimmed to compensate?

---

## 8. What is not known — stated plainly

- **The ground.** No soil information of any kind. This is the single biggest gap and it cannot be
  answered by drawing.
- **The concrete's actual strength.** Bagged mix, no strength cited.
- **The ring's permissible tilt moment** from igus for the 185 mm sealed ring. The load tables are
  published per size class and will be obtained; the service-life computation through igus' PRT
  configurator is also still outstanding.
- **The final weight.** The itemised masses are computed from the drawing, and the bowl masses in
  particular are estimates from material thickness (0.95 lb each). A built piece within ±10% is
  realistic, and the balance point is the number most sensitive to it.
- **Whether the county will require a licensed Colorado design professional** for this structure.
  The county's own code document says one may be required for structures in special wind regions,
  and this county has them. Assume yes.

---

## 9. How these numbers were produced

Everything in sections 3 and 4 comes from one data file and one tool, both in this repository, so
every figure in this brief can be recomputed and checked line by line rather than taken on trust:

    python3 scripts/slow_bloom_loads.py --file output/slow-bloom-load-inputs.json

- `output/slow-bloom-load-inputs.json` — the geometry, the itemised masses with the source of each
  one, the wind-catch areas with their lever arms, the design wind, and the list of the things that
  are still unknown. Nothing in it is a design value.
- `scripts/slow_bloom_loads.py` + `schemas/slow_bloom_loads.schema.json` — rolls those up into the
  masses, the centre of gravity, the imbalance, the trim authority, the areas with their arms, and
  the bare code velocity pressure. It states in its own output that it is not a design and returns
  no design value.

**And, restated because it is the whole point of this document: the check itself has not been done
here and cannot be done here. A licensed structural engineer does that, and the answer is his to
give.** This brief is the pile of paper he starts from.

---

## 10. What happens next

1. **Mike takes this brief to a licensed Colorado structural engineer** (or asks for a name through
   the county's building department, which sees this wind region regularly).
2. The engineer returns a design — pier diameter and depth, reinforcement and ties, concrete
   specification, anchor type and pattern, plate and weld details, and the wind case he worked to.
3. **Only then** does anything get ordered. The schedule that follows is in `docs/slow-bloom.md`
   §5.3, and it is driven by one number: the sealed main ring's 25–30 working day lead time.
4. The design changes go back into `docs/slow-bloom.md` and the bill of materials, and the totals
   are recomputed.

Nothing is ordered, cut or welded in the meantime.
